I run a lot more than I cycle or swim. Mainly because I'm a way better runner (ha, everything's relative!) than cyclist or swimmer and I have a marathon to run in April. I only cycle about once a week, if I'm lucky and I haven't really been swimming at all lately.
I finally dragged myself to the pool after about a month of just talking about how I should really go to the pool. It took a lot of moral support, including a pastry as a reward at the end but for the first time, I did half or more than half of the swim session without this:
This giant styrofoam peanut looking thing is called a pull buoy (pronounced 'boy' which just inevitably makes me think of pool boys...) and is a floatation device designed to help beginners focus on arm drills while they swim, or try to learn how, without sinking. This way, you can work on arms and then kicking separately before trying to put it all together, which can be overwhelming for those of us who didn't grow up swimming... If you're puzzled, don't worry, I had never seen a pull buoy before I started swimming with my tri club.
Here's a little flashback to my first tri team swim session and my introduction to swimming the crawl:
Me, gasping for breath (after probably 1 or 2 lengths...): I have no endurance, I just get so tired!
Coach: Here, use this.
Me: Um, what is that and what do I do with it?
Coach, suprised that there were people on earth unfamiliar with pull buoys: It goes between your legs.
Me, surprised that swimming involved putting something between your legs: Really? How high up between your legs exactly?
If you were wondering, there is absoultely nothing sexy about pull buoys at all despite the fact that they go between your thighs... You forget it's there because you're usually too busy trying to breathe properly or to do some weird impossible drill like extend your arms out all the way, swim using only one hand or lift up your elbows (that's called Shark Fin and it's my favorite because the only basic swimming technique that I think I can do right).
The drill I'm proudest of being able to do (with the help of Mr. Pull Buoy) is swimming with my hands clenched into fists. This makes you realise how inefficient your entire stroke and really everything you do is and I feel like it's a mental victory to make it from one the end of the pool to the other with the fists of fury. Surprisingly, I now find bilateral breathing pretty easy, but it's everything else (arm position, keeping your head far enough in the water, keeping your core tight and kicking enough but not too much) that I find really hard.
Swimming involves a lot of weird impossible drills because it's the most technical of the 3 triathlon sports. It really doesn't matter how fit you are, it just matters if you have the right technique. I used to hate this and find it unfair being in good running shape doesn't mean that you're in good swimming shape, but now I think that in some ways it's nice, since I will probably never be as fit as a lot of the triathletes I know. Since I can't compete with them in terms of fitness, I like that I might someday be capable of learning good swimming technique and find it strangely comforting that you just have to be efficient in the water and if you are, then it's ok if you're not particularly strong or able to do a thousand push ups or run a blazing fast 3 hour marathon...
Interestingly, a swimming coach in the US once told me that the land sport that prepared people best for being a good swimmer was ballet. Running and cycling are all about contracting your muscles, but swimming and dancing are both about lengthening your muscles.
I've also heard from some swim coaches (mainly charming Australian swim coach Breton Ford) that teaching complete beginners is really difficult, a lot of coaches have no idea how and are much more comfortable helping experienced swimmers shave 10 seconds off their time. I am lucky enough to have some great coaches on my tri team and think they're definitely much better at spotting problems and devising drills to correct them than lifeguards at the local pool. Anyone who asks me about swimming lessons (or for a recommendation for a gym to join), just gets a little promotional sales talk about why they should join the tri team and it's better and cheaper than gyms or private swim lessons.
The tri team will also never tell you that you're hopeless. You may go down in tri team history as being a legendarily bad swimmer, but they will keep coaching you. To go back to my first swim session ever, the coach's main comment after a few laps last November? 'We have a lot of work to do!'
So what have we learned today? We already know that swimming is hard because it's so technique- based. But for any beginner swimmers out there, remember that the pull buoy is your magic friend and really does make a big difference when you are learning to do the impossible (swim) and you'll be glad to have it for your swimming drills.